Property photo 1
Property photo 2
Property photo 3
Property photo 4
Property photo 5
7 Beds
5 Baths
4,464 sqft

$3,790,000

31 Josiah Sachem Way, West Tisbury MA, 02575

Price per sqft$849.01
Built in1972
Property size4,464 sqft
Property typeResidential

Overview

Active

Listed Oct 9, 2026

Updated 3h ago

THE COMPOUND AT INDIAN HILL Three dwellings. One price. One house decides how you live. Three let you change your mind. More than three private acres in West Tisbury. 4,464 square feet across three buildings, each with its own front door. The Main House holds the center. Glass doors & generous windows pull the meadow inside. A stone fireplace anchors the room. The kitchen was built for dinners that run long. The Studio Barn is the open question. Four sets of French doors swing wide to a wildflower meadow, & the room goes with them. Artist's studio. Wellness space. Whatever you have been missing. The Guest House earns its keep. Three bedrooms, a loft-inspired living space, & a long rental history. Seven bedrooms. Four & a half baths. A heated saltwater pool. A full compound, or a primary residence with income built in. Lambert's Cove & Long Point beaches, farm stands, & Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary. Walk to the market, apothecary, & post office. Rural enough to disappear into. Close enough to never feel cut off. Most homes are bought for one season of life. This one was built to hold many. Septic capacity for up to 10 bedrooms. Buyer to verify with West Tisbury Board of Health. On the gentle slopes of Indian Hill, more than three private acres hold a main house, a studio barn, & a guest house. 4,464 square feet in all. Wildflower meadows run between them. Layered perennial gardens soften the edges. A heated saltwater pool sits at the center, looking borrowed from a private resort. This is not a house with outbuildings. It is a quiet, self-sufficient world of its own. THE MAIN HOUSE | 2,088 SF Glass doors & generous windows pull the landscape inside. Every room frames meadow or garden. A stone fireplace grounds the living room, which opens to a sweeping dining area & a gracious, well-appointed kitchen. It handles a holiday table for twenty as easily as a Tuesday night for two. THE STUDIO BARN | 1,152 SF The open question. Four sets of French doors swing wide to the wildflower meadow, & the room goes with them. Set apart & private by design. Artist's studio. Yoga & wellness space. A place to retreat & reset. Few Island properties come with this much possibility already built. THE GUEST HOUSE | 1,224 SF Two stories, three bedrooms, one & a half baths, & a loft-inspired living space, tucked quietly on its own. Its long history as a leased rental means the income is not a projection. It is a record. Long-term tenants, visiting guests, the people you want close: this house has already done the job. Seven bedrooms. Four & a half baths. One heated saltwater pool. Arrange it as you like. A full compound for everyone you love. A primary residence with income built in. Or something in between that only you will think of. West Tisbury at its best. Lambert's Cove & Long Point beaches. Cedar Tree Neck Sanctuary for the long walk. Farm stands, village eateries, trails, & bike paths. Market, apothecary, post office, & cafes are an easy stroll. Most homes are bought for one season of life. This one was built to hold many. Three dwellings, two septic systems, capacity for up to 10 bedrooms. Buyer to verify with West Tisbury Board of Health.

$25,215/mo

Est. mortgage payment based on a $3,790,000 home price.

All estimates are provided by Luxury Presence for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

Additional information

MLS® ID
22605167

Interior Features

Bedrooms
7
Bathrooms
5
Fireplace
Yes
Cooling
Yes
Heating
Yes
Basement
Yes

Exterior Features

Lot Size
3.1 Acres

Other Property Details

Taxes
$11,390
Tax Frequency
Annually

Courtesy of Studio Realty LLC, Peyton Wallace

The data relating to real estate for sale on this site comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Cape Cod & Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. (CCIMLS). Real estate listings provided by CCIMLS and held by brokerage firms other than Cape Island Estates are marked with the CCIMLS BR Logo and detailed information includes, at minimum, the name of the listing agent and broker attribution assigned by the listing broker. This site was last updated 10/11/2026. Neither the listing broker nor Cape Island Estates shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, or misprints and shall be held totally harmless. All properties are subject to prior sale, changes, or withdrawal.

Copyright© 2026 Cape Cod and Islands Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.

Powered by Luxury Presence